Top 10 Affordable Horse Feed Buckets
Hook — the bucket that taught me patience
A few winters back, I bought what looked like a “clever” clip-on feeder. It promised zero-spill and “indestructible” plastic. Two days later my mare found a way to unclip it, fling oats across the stall, and make a sandcastle of her bedding. That sound — grain thudding, bedding puffing up, and her satisfied crunching — taught me an important thing: durability + simplicity > clever gimmicks. Since then I’ve tried and kept the ones that survive thunder, boredom, and the occasional tantrum.
What I look for in an affordable feed bucket
Short list — because when you’re juggling tack, feed bags, and a grumpy gelding, you don’t want long lists:
-
Flat-back design that sits flush on stall walls or doors (less tipping).
-
Sturdy handle or hanging hooks — not just tiny plastic tabs.
-
Thick, flexible material (rubber or heavy polyethylene) — resists cracking in cold.
-
5–6 quart capacity for most daily grain, larger tubs for water or big feedings.
-
Easy to clean; grain smell and oil build-up attract bugs — nobody wants that.
(If you want a compact, widely available option, the Little Giant flat-back plastic buckets have been reliably affordable and durable in my barn.)
Top 10 affordable picks (short notes + why I liked/ditched them)
-
Little Giant Flat-Back Plastic Bucket (8 qt) — classic, light, cheap, and fits on stall rings; easy to wash and doesn’t retain odors. Great starter favorite.
-
Miller Rubber Corner Bucket (5 gal, rubber) — heavier, nearly indestructible; I’ve used these outdoors for water all winter — they survive freezing and rough handling. The rubber has a reassuring “thud” when you set it down.
-
Lock N Load Mountable Feed Bucket (polyethylene) — clips solidly to fences, less tipping for horses who turn buckets into toys. Good value for the durability.
-
Little Giant Better Bucket (ergonomic lip) — easier to carry when mixed feed is heavy; less messy pouring (wish I’d had this when I was lugging mash at dawn).
-
Rubber trough-style pans (generic 2–3 gal) — shallow, wide pans for picky horses who like to root in feed; they’re cheap and quick to clean.
-
Tough1 canvas/nylon feed bags (for travel/trail) — not a bucket, but invaluable when you want mess-free travel feeds. I once fed on a windy trail — the canvas bag cut down on fly-throw and waste.
-
Slow-feeder inserts / web hay bags — for those on a budget who want to slow munching; I use these in winter to prevent boredom and reduce hay waste.
-
3–4 qt shallow plastic pans (budget sets) — cheap, color-coded for each horse (helps with supplements and meds). I learned the hard way — don’t leave them on the floor too long or horses will stand on them.
-
Rubber feed tubs (2–6 gal) — multipurpose: feed, water, hoof soaking. Smell-wise, rubber keeps a “barny” scent that somehow says ‘this belongs here’.
-
DIY bucket with feed bag combo — an old 5-gallon with a fitted feed bag (saves spill and you can toss in supplements). Cheap, customizable, and taught me to be resourceful when a supplier was out of stock.
Real-life mistakes & lessons
-
Mistake: Bought too many “clip-on” novelty buckets.
Lesson: Clips break. Horses experiment. Simplicity wins. -
Mistake: Using thin plastic buckets outside in winter. They cracked overnight.
Lesson: Get a rubber or thick polyethylene bucket for cold climates — they flex instead of shattering. -
Mistake: Not color-coding feed buckets for horses on different supplements. Result: one grainy mishap and a week of upset stomachs.
Lesson: Use colored buckets or labels — cheap insurance.
Regional/seasonal and breed notes
-
In wet, cold regions (think damp winters), rubber tubs hold up much better — plastic becomes brittle in the freeze.
-
In hot/dry regions, dust and ants are the enemy — elevated or hanging buckets reduce bug contamination.
-
Draft horses vs. Arabians: big-barrel breeds often "step" in taller, narrower buckets; shallow, wide pans work better for them. My heavy Percheron once used a 5-gallon like a footrest — don't laugh, but size matters.
It would be even better if…
It would be even better if manufacturers added replaceable rubber lips on flat-back buckets to reduce cracking where they meet metal brackets — small design change, big longevity improvement. Also — a built-in anti-tilt notch or clip that actually withstands a bored gelding’s antics would be a barn-saver.
My personal top pick (practical link you can use)
For a straightforward, affordable, reliable option I recommend starting with the Little Giant Flat-Back Plastic Bucket — I keep a set in the trailer and stalls because they’re light, stack, and clean easily. Here’s a product page you can use:
Actionable tips (do this tomorrow)
-
Color-code or label buckets for supplements.
-
Hang buckets when flies are bad — fewer pests and less waste.
-
Rotate rubber tubs outdoors in winter; bring in lighter plastic ones for stalls if temps are mild.
-
Clean weekly — grain oils and dust build up fast; I scrape, rinse, and sun-dry mine.
Short FAQs (barn-chat style)
Q: “How often should I replace a cheap bucket?” — When you see cracks, stiff brittleness, or if it starts smelling like old grain. Don’t wait for the heartbreak.
Q: “Slow feeder or regular bucket?” — Slow feeder if you’ve got a cribber, fast eater, or metabolic-prone horse; regular bucket for quick portioned grain.
Q: “Can I use water buckets for feed?” — Sure, but they’ll retain smells. I prefer separate tubs to avoid cross-contamination.
Q: “My horse flips buckets — suggestions?” — Try a flat-back, wall-mounted option or heavy rubber tubs that aren’t easy to tip.
Final takeaway — watch, learn, tweak
Buckets aren’t glamorous — but neither is wasted grain, an upset horse, or a cracked meal in a blizzard. Watch how your horse interacts with the feeder for a week or two after any change. Little cues — the way they press their nose in, how they paw, how quickly they forage — will tell you what to tweak. Start simple, choose durable, and color-code your life.
Comments
Post a Comment